In Sarasota, it’s pretty easy to find unique dining options. In fact, there are amazing places to eat in just about every part of town. Here are some of our favorite cool places to eat in Sarasota.
Life’s a beach, but in Sarasota and the surrounding area, it’s so much more. It’s a foodie’s delight. You can find just about any type of cuisine and atsmophere imaginable. From quaint breakfast spots to upscale waterside eateries and “Old Florida” vibes, it’s nearly impossible to run out of tantalizing options.
If you’re looking for the perfect restaurant to match your mood, we’ve got you covered. Check out Sarasota’s unique dining options.
Chart House Longboat Key
Imagine catching a glimpse of a playful dolphin splashing in the bay while you enjoy herb-crusted prime rib, creamed spinach, and boursin potato soufflé. Of course, we can’t guarantee the dolphin, but the culinary adventure is one you’ll never forget.
Chart House is a Sarasota favorite for special occasions. And if you’re lucky enough to get an outside table right around sunset, you’ll feel like you’re watching a postcard come to life. And be sure to try the boursin potato soufflé. It’s out-of-this-world yummy!
Ophelia’s on the Bay Siesta Key
Ophelia’s is a top choice for seafood lovers, but land lovers will not be disappointed. This beloved restaurant boasts one of the best waterfront views of any restaurant in the Sarasota area. You’ll enjoy amazing dishes like Hawaiian tuna tartare nachos, rack of lamb and boneless duckling while taking in the spectacular views. Please note that it can be tough to get a table during high season, so make your reservations far in advance.
Indigenous
You can’t talk about cool places to eat in Sarasota without mentioning this awesome find. Located in the historic Towles Court district in downtown Sarasota, Indigenous is known for its commitment to sustainable seafood, locally sourced ingredients and unique dishes. Chef Steve Phelps brings his expert cooking techniques to this celebrated dining destination. Indulge in seasonally rotating dishes like baked scallops and pork belly, all paired with expertly curated wines for a truly unforgettable dining experience.
Selva Grill
For delicious Latin American fusion cuisine, Selva Grill is a favorite amongst locals and tourists alike. A downtown Sarasota staple, this Peruvian eatery delights the palette with artfully plated dishes that have been recognized by national publications like The New York Times. Indulge in starters like empanadas or short rib spring rolls. Then, tantalize your taste buds with main dishes like Andean rack of lamb or tofu and rice with shiitake mushrooms.
Shore
You can’t go wrong with either of Shore’s fabulous locations. Shore St. Armand’s Circle is the place to go for a chic, sophisticated vibe followed by cocktails with a group. And Shore Longboat Key is the perfect dining destination for those seeking a picturesque view. Both locations have equally amazing food with unique dishes and incredible seafood. Indulge in one-of-a-kind offerings like roasted corn and goat cheese polenta salad or ahi tuna mignon. And consider opting for truffle mac and cheese as a side.
Yoder’s Restaurant & Amish Village
For down-home comfort food, there is no better option than Yoder’s Restaurant & Amish Village. In the 1970s, Levi and Amanda Yoder sold their Indiana farm to move to Sarasota. That move started the Sarasota tradition of dining at the beloved Yoder’s Restaurant. Not only will you encounter fascinating Amish culture on your visit, the food is fabulous. From amazing fried chicken to tasty shrimp and cheesy grits, Yoder’s Restaurant is an adventure for your taste buds.
Linger Lodge
This awesome find tops our list of Sarasota’s unique dining options. For an “Old Florida” atmosphere, check out Linger Lodge Restaurant. The menu includes many Florida favorites, such as alligator and frog legs. A visit to this restaurant is also a historical adventure. Linger Lodge was originally established as a two-story log cabin in 1945. Visitors are fascinated by the taxidermy creatures that fill the property, like an action-posed fox, an alligator and numerous snakes. In fact, Al Roker once named Linger Lodge one of the five weirdest restaurants in the country. A visit to this Sarasota area favorite can best be described as, well, extremely fun!
The Breakfast House
Hello pancakes! You won’t find pancakes anywhere else like you will at The Breakfast House. Oh my goodness, they are unforgettably tasty! Favorites include chocolate chip, lemon lavender, stuffed blueberry and coconut and white nut pancakes. And if you’re looking for a healthier option, consider the vegan skillet. In addition, you can find gluten-free items like gluten-free stuffed French toast.
Sarasota’s restaurant scene is as unique and vibrant as the city itself. Whether you’re looking for an “Old Florida” vibe or a fine dining option with spectacular waterfront views, you’ll find it in this Gulf Coast paradise. Sarasota’s best restaurants promise a culinary journey that will delight and inspire. Enjoy these cool places to eat in Sarasota. Happy dining!